← Card Scout

How much are my Pokémon cards worth?

There is no reliable price for “an old Pokémon card” without identifying the card and its condition. The name alone is not enough: different printings of the same Pokémon can have very different prices.

Tobias Mooney

By Tobias Mooney, Card Scout

Collection buyer who personally reviews every submission

Not sure what you have? Start with photos.

Send a few clear photos. Tobias will personally review your cards and tell you what he can offer, usually the same day.

Send photos for an offer

1. Identify the exact card

Before comparing prices, record the card's name and collector number, usually printed near the bottom. Match the set, artwork, language and finish too. A holo, reverse holo, different edition or reprint should not automatically be compared with a different version.

If you cannot identify it, leave it as it is and send a clear photo. You do not need to research every card before asking Card Scout for an offer.

2. Look at condition on both sides

Check the corners, edges and surface. Whitening on the back, scratches, creases and bends can affect what a buyer will pay. Two copies of the same card can sell for different amounts if one is worn and the other is much cleaner.

Take front and back photos of cards you think may stand out. Avoid glare and show damage rather than hiding it. A photo review is not an official grade, and a clean-looking card is not automatically a top-grade card.

Do not clean, wipe or flatten cards to improve their appearance. Keep them dry and protected while you decide what to do.

3. Compare completed sales, not just listings

A seller can ask any price. A completed sale is a better reference for what a buyer actually paid. Look for several recent sales matching the exact card, language, printing and similar condition rather than picking the highest result.

TCGplayer describes its Market Price as based on recent sales transactions, rather than current asking prices. That can be a reference point, but it is not a guaranteed offer for your own copy.

Source: TCGplayer's explanation of Market Price ↗

For marketplace comparisons, also check whether the sale includes shipping, multiple cards or a graded holder. Those differences can make an apparent match misleading.

4. Understand collection value versus retail value

Adding up individual retail prices does not tell you what a buyer will offer for a whole box. Selling each card involves identifying, listing, fees, packing and finding buyers. A collection buyer takes on that work and the risk that some cards do not sell.

At Card Scout, Tobias looks at the cards, their condition and comparable sales before making an offer. The offer is for the collection described in your photos. It is not a formal appraisal, and inspection confirms the cards match the submission.

What if I have hundreds of cards?

Start with binder pages or cards spread out in small groups. Add close-ups of unusual-looking, shiny or graded cards and an overview of the boxes or stacks. This helps show both standout cards and the size of the collection without making you catalogue it.

Some older cards are sought after, but age alone does not make every card valuable. Mixed collections need to be reviewed on their own merits; we do not promise a price before seeing the photos.

Find out what Tobias can offer for your cards

Send a few clear photos. Tobias will personally review your cards and tell you what he can offer, usually the same day.

Send photos for an offer

More help with your collection